BeatlesFan wrote:Interesting.
Before voting it is important to note that each of the debaters does not get to pick their position. They could just as easily have been assigned to argue the exact opposite. With that in mind, I had to look at the substance and persuasiveness of what they did with "the hand that was dealt to them". I think that Highlander was better able to support and persuade toward his position.
I say interesting, because I don't agree with that view at all...but given his starting point I think that he did the better job of articulating/persuading so he gets my vote on this round.
I agree. He did a much better job, and in the future I will be more persuasive and charismatic. (or at least try)