- Every official clan-match should be moderated by a mod (or a person with spectator privileges) or the end result must be documented in a screenshot. These count in ranking and the screenshot should clearly show the names of the players
- Any non-moderated/non-screenshot clan match would be considered a friendly match that does not count in ranking.
- The maps for official clan-matches must be approved by the Vortex Wars forum community. For best results, at least 5 members and 1 moderator should agree.
- The Clan-match results must contain (not in this order):
1.Result 2.Map 3.Clans 4.Player number 5.Evidence
Notes: The Map should include the determined settings such as (HC, Full map)
The evidence should contain either the Nickname of the spectating mod or link to the screenshot
With 4 of these "rules" the Clan idea would be already standardized.
Also, I believe that the clan inside politics (ranks (such as veterans), number of members) are up to the Founders of the clan since this does not affect other clans directly.
Edited: But if the individual players want to be ranked and compared in between clans, there should also be a standardized ranking system. For instance:
- If clan wars occur in a 1v1 until either clan runs out of members (if it's 5v5, the score could be 4-5), the individual players could be ranked on the number of such matches won and lost (ratio)
- If it's a 2v2 or 3v3 or 4v4 and individual players would want to be ranked, a system of gaining half or a similar number of what 1v1 would get.
- Another idea would be to keep records of the individual players matches to rank them, I will make a hypothetical example of me:Betagen (Won/Lost):
1v1: (4/5) 2v2: (2/3) 3v3: (0/0)
And so on...
P.S. The reason I'm suggesting a standardized system is because the forum has not yet expanded too much and it could be controlled. But when over 20 clans with at least 7 members in each form, it will really be difficult to track bullshit at least 4 forum members join everyday and you see how much has recently changed due to 3-5 new active members.
Edited: referring to Clan War rules: http://vortexwars.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=1730
- Due to different timezones of players or lack of time a match can be adjourned or cancelled. This should not be considered as a loss.
- The accepted/delayed clan war challenge should be notified in the clan page first post. This could also apply to the results.